Around this time last year, I participated in a couple of panel discussion for my alma mater. The theme for both was what you can do with an Arts career, and I was selected because a) I have an Arts degree, b) I have a job, c) and I said yes.
The first one didn’t go so great. I started getting sick about five minutes beforehand, and spent the next hour feeling increasingly uncomfortable. There’s a joke about my brother’s wedding that you can look at pictures and tell what time of night it was based on how many clothes I was wearing on the dance floor: I started in a three-piece tux and somehow ended up in jeans and a tee-shirt. It was the same thing at the panel: I entered dressed properly, but my body decided to overheat until I was down to jeans and a rolled-up shirt. I also left twice for bathroom breaks, infinitely more times than the rest of the panel and moderators combined. The actual discussion went by without a hitch, but would you take life advice from a sweaty stripper who gave the impression that he needed to ESCAPE! at the drop of a hat? Me neither.
The second one went a lot better. I left work and headed over to the landing area where I’d meet the two others on my panel. Only one was there, Josh (same name as my brother), and after making our introductions he gave me a strange look and asked “are you famous? I think I know you from somewhere.” For a delusional second I thought that I was famous and he was just being coy; of course he knew who I was! But no, I ran through the list of places he might know me from and came up empty. The conversation turned to my cardigan, and we moved on.
There were two panel sessions that night, with a short break in the middle. It was me, a girl who worked in the private sector as a recruiter, and Josh, who was an unemployed photographer/journalist/recent father of twins. They both had notes with planned-out answers based on the questions we’d been provided ahead of time. I had nothing, and borrowed some paper from the girl so I could doodle while we talked. I learned long ago that preparing what I want to say ahead of time inevitably leads to disaster, and I fare much better just knowing as much as possible about the given subject and winging the actual content.
I was my brother’s best man and decided, along with my sister-in-law’s sister, that we would each focus on our own sibling for our mutual speeches. The day before the wedding she wanted to compare notes to make sure we covered everything, and she showed me her beautifully written speech. I gave her “I don’t know, I’ll figure it out tomorrow” in return. She laughed nervously.
The next morning I scribbled a few things I didn’t want to forget on a Post-It note: La-La’s boots (I used to call Josh La-La, and when we were two and four respectively, I proudly burst into his pre-school class with “La-La’s boots! La-La’s boots!”), the fact that he taught me to read when I was three because I wanted to be more like him, and that he was easily the most influential person in my life. It *killed*. Four laugh breaks and leaving the audience in tears killed. Whenever I need a public speaking confidence boost, I think back to that memory.
So the panel started and I spent 45 minutes answering questions about my life and doodling (poorly) audience members. Not as much fun as I’d hoped, but the students liked what we had to say. We took our break, I had a bite to eat, and it was time for the second session. Newly energized, I suddenly found myself bored and started thinking about how awful it must be to be famous and answer the same questions over and over again. I decided that I’d already answered my questions the same way twice and had no desire to do that again.
When it comes to the “how did you end up at your current career” question, I have a very long story that involves five schools, three provinces, four distinct areas of study, a lesbian rock star, a miserable year off, a student job involving NASA, an absurd amount of course credits, sporadic moves across the country, a well-timed University recruiter, and the Pacific Ocean. The first and second times around I focused on the scholastic route, answering what I thought I was supposed to say. This third time, I focused on the lesbian rock star and how, during a game of Asshole at a Montréal café, she gave me the idea of moving to Vancouver. I stopped answering questions directly, and instead tried making parables of my life stories. I had a lot more fun, and the audience was a lot more engaged.
When someone asked about money, I launched into my story about Steve, my best friend’s father. When I first moved to Québec, I became best friends with a guy who lived down the street—the kind of best friends who, fifteen years later, can still find themselves awake at 3am five days in a row talking about anything from computational math to religion. Steve, however, was never my biggest fan—he described me as “spacey” and assumed I was stoned most of the time (coincidentally, this occurred during my misguided straight-edge phase). It got worse as I got older, and the majority of our interactions involved him making fun of my hair, piercings, and clothes, while I silently pitied and ignored him.
Before I moved to Vancouver, I was at Greg’s house to say goodbye to his family when Steve saunters up the stairs. I let bygones be bygones and was prepared to bid him farewell with a handshake when he launched into a speech about how irresponsible I was. I should be staying at home to finish school, student loans are going to put me in debt, I should have stuck with Science or Commerce, etc. I kind of lost it and cut him off:
Are you kidding me? I’ve known you for eight years, and not once have I seen you happy! You hate your job, you’re out of shape, and you spent your free time alone in your basement! How do you possibly think you have the right to tell me what I should be doing? Even if I end up broke and working a minimum wage job, I’m still going to be more successful than you because I’m never going to end up a miserable little bastard enjoys insulting other people. So yes, I’m going to throw myself into huge debt, study a field with no guaranteed career, and I’m going to enjoy every second of it!
Then I shook his hand and left.
To sum up the story, I said “whatever you do, don’t be like Steve.” If you only think about how much money you’re going to have, you’re probably not going to be happy and that is infinitely more important. If you want to do something and someone tells you that you can’t, you should probably do it. Be in debt if you have to, screw up a few times, but make sure you’re happy. An older gentleman in the audience laughed nervously.
I was asked about what to do when you’re in the last year of your degree and still aren’t sure what to do. I answered “stay in school for another year and learn something new, maybe you’ll love that. An extra year, even five extra years, in your 20s will always be shorter than the rest of your life; you will never regret it.” I’ve always been somewhat terrified of those people who, at 17, know exactly what they want to do with their lives and go through their schooling with a singular purpose. There’s jealousy in my terror, but the idea of 17 year old me making life decisions for the current one is an absolutely horrifying proposal.
The rest of the discussion went really well until the moderator made a joke about getting one of the ladies in the audience to answer a question. I leaned close into the mic and, in my best baritone radio voice, said “this one goes out to the laaaaadies.” If you’ve seen that Demetri Martin bit, you can probably guess the faces on the audience.
Afterwards we had a meet-and-greet for students for follow-up questions. To my surprise I wasn’t completely shunned, and spent the next hour talking to students who appreciated what I had to say. One person said “I like how you say things. I like the words you use.” I’m still not completely sure what that means, but it’s a nice-sounding compliment and I like it.
Once that ended, Josh and I decided to grab a beer and headed to the pub. Throughout the night, various students joined us and there was another hour of talking. The guy on my right spontaneously announced his bisexuality—I thought it was just an abrupt subject change, so I launched into my story about the lesbian rock star. Eventually I clued in and explained I wasn’t interested, but instead of him getting embarrassed, we ended up having a really enlightening conversation about sexuality in the Muslim culture. It was pretty awesome.
Turns out it was open mic night at the pub, and the host came to our table asking if anyone wanted to play. I was in that content stage right before drunk and did not think I wanted to, but apparently my face said otherwise. Josh volunteered to do a few songs, and the host kept pestering me: “it’s so obvious you want to get on stage!” She was right. I didn’t want to sing, but I spotted a piano and agreed to accompany Josh.
There were three problems with the situation: 1) I didn’t know what songs Josh wanted to play, 2) I’d never played piano onstage, and 3) while I love playing piano, I’m not very good. It was close to our turn, so I asked Josh about the songs he wanted to do: “The Gambler,” some Grateful Dead song I’d never heard, and “Sweat” (you know, “a la la la la long”). “Don’t worry,” he said when I told him about my lack of piano skills. “They’re all really easy to play.”
I asked him to tell me the chords, and with an evil grin he said: “No.” I responded with “what do you mean ‘no’?!” Our names were called. We walked to the stage and I asked him what the chords were for the first song. “It starts with G.” We settled into our positions and I asked him what the rest were. “No.” Suddenly I was bickering onstage with someone I’d met three hours earlier, and he eventually agreed to at least turn his guitar towards me.
Like the first two panels, the first two songs went OK. There’s a chord in “The Gambler” I didn’t like for moralistic reasons and kept forgetting to play it, but by the end of the Grateful Dead song I was really getting into it. He started playing “Sweat” and it’s a really easy song, so I didn’t have to think about the notes I had to hit. We were two very dorky white guys playing an absurd folk rock version of a reggae song, and I figured that the only way out was to just push through. I stopped playing stabs, moved down a couple octaves, and started a lush accompaniment with walking bass lines, arpeggios, and generally anything else you would hear in an 80s rock ballad. It was awesome ridiculous and I was having the time of my life. Josh’s uncontrollable grin the first time I threw in an F# was priceless.
The song ended and the small crowd erupted. My new bisexual friend gave me one of those awkward high five/back slap combos that only happens three drinks in, and the host came over to say “I told you so! You loved every second of that!” Like I said, it was awesome ridiculous, and it was fun.
I sat down and suddenly thought about Steve. Over the years we have arrived at a healthy respect for each other, and get along quite well these days. I remembered how, years ago when he was learning to play piano, he asked me to help him figure out a symbol on the sheet music for “Titanic.” It was a sweeping arpeggio that went across four octaves, and he complained that his hands don’t stretch like that. I told him that it didn’t matter, just play what he could and it will sound good. He refused, claiming that it was all or nothing. It was more important for him to play the song as someone else wrote it down than it was to enjoy the song.
Utah Philips tells a story that includes the line “if the only true life I have is the life of my brain, what sense does it make to hand that brain over to someone for eight hours a day to do with what they please? That’s stupid.” It’s a little more elegant than “don’t be like Steve,” but the message is the same.
Original post.